Maybe Logo Early Access
November 13, 2024 — 24 min read

10 Reasons Not to Lease a Car: What You Need to Know

Josh Pigford

Author

Josh Pigford

Those attractive monthly payments make car leasing tempting. Car leasing might look like a budget-friendly option at first. Your financial health could be at risk for years if you make the wrong choice between leasing and buying a car.

The decision needs careful thought about credit score requirements, mileage limits, and wear-and-tear charges. A lease brings complex agreements and fewer customization options. The higher long-term costs could hurt your financial plans. A clear understanding of these limits will help you choose your next vehicle wisely.

Higher Overall Cost

The numbers reveal a surprising story in the total cost comparison between leasing and buying a car. Monthly lease payments appear attractive to many buyers, but the long-term costs turn out to be substantially higher.

Long-term expense comparison

This is a big deal as it means that leasing costs more than buying, particularly if you lease multiple times. Let's break down the costs for a $36,000 vehicle:

Cost Factor 3-Year Lease Purchase (6 Years)
Down Payment $1,000 $3,600
Monthly Payments $500 x 36 $450 x 72
Total Payments $19,000 $36,000
Asset Value $0 $19,500

Hidden fees and charges

The advertised monthly payments don't tell the whole story. You'll face many more costs:

Depreciation factor

Your lease payments cover the steepest part of a vehicle's value drop. A new car loses up to 50% of its value in just three years. You end up paying for this huge drop without getting anything back.

Here's a real example: A new car priced at $36,000 drops to $19,500 after three years. You'll spend $19,000 on lease payments and walk away empty-handed. The same car bought instead of leased would give you an asset worth $19,500, despite the value drop.

The money drain gets worse if you keep leasing new vehicles. Every new lease starts another cycle of high payments that eat away the car's value. This creates an endless loop where you pay top dollar but build zero long-term value.

Limited Mileage

Car lease agreements limit your driving freedom with mileage restrictions, which are the most important constraints to consider. Car owners can drive unlimited miles, but lease contracts set strict mileage caps that affect how much you can drive.

Typical mileage restrictions

Standard lease agreements typically restrict your annual mileage between 5,000 to 12,000 miles. The average American's yearly driving distance is about 14,000 miles. High-mileage lease options are available, but they cost more each month. A Honda Accord's standard lease at 12,000 miles per year costs $289 monthly, and this is a big deal as it means that the same car with a 100,000-mile lease term increases to $467 monthly.

Overage charges

Going beyond your mileage limit costs extra money. These are the typical charges you should know about:

Mileage Type Cost Impact
Standard Limit Included in lease
Over-limit fee ~$0.30 per mile
1,000 miles over $300 extra
5,000 miles over $1,500 extra

Impact on lifestyle

Going over your mileage limits can shake up your daily life in several ways:

These limits can really mess with your lifestyle if you love road trips or have an unpredictable commute. You might catch yourself checking the odometer all the time. Worse yet, you could end up saying no to plans that need driving just to stay within your lease limits.

High-mileage lease options are out there, but they cost 60-75% more than regular leases. This extra cost wipes out one of leasing's main perks - lower monthly payments. You should think over whether this premium makes sense compared to buying a car outright.

No Ownership Equity

Picture throwing money into a bottomless pit - that's what happens when you lease a car instead of building ownership equity through purchasing. We should get into how this impacts your financial future.

Lack of asset building

Monthly payments on a leased vehicle amount to long-term renting. Your payments toward a car loan build ownership equity, but lease payments only provide temporary use of the vehicle. The math tells a clear story: A $500 monthly payment over three years adds up to $18,000 without any ownership stake at the end.

Buying vs Leasing

The numbers tell an interesting story when we look at a three-year period:

Financial Aspect Leasing Buying
Monthly Payment $500 $550
Total Paid $18,000 $19,800
Asset Value After 3 Years $0 $19,500
Net Financial Position -$18,000 -$300

Long-term financial implications

Leasing a car without building equity leads to several financial drawbacks:

Here's a real-life example: A $36,000 car loses about half its value in three years. Buyers still own an asset worth $19,500 even after this depreciation. Lessees pay almost the same amount ($18,000) and end up with nothing.

Monthly lease payments cover the car's steepest depreciation period. The car's remaining value brings no benefit to you. This creates an endless cycle where you pay for the most expensive part of a car's life. You never build long-term wealth through vehicle ownership.

Repeated leasing locks you into endless car payments. A buyer who keeps their car after paying off the loan drives payment-free. They own a valuable asset they can sell or trade in later.

Excess Wear and Tear Charges

Car leases have strict rules about keeping the vehicle in good condition. Breaking these rules can result in hefty financial penalties. You can avoid thousands in unexpected charges by reading and understanding the requirements before you sign the lease agreement.

Strict return conditions

Lease agreements have specific standards your vehicle must meet when you return it. These standards measure acceptable wear with exact specifications:

What it all means for unexpected costs

Leased vehicle returns can hit your wallet with charges that weren't part of your original budget:

Damage Type Typical Cost Range
Paint repair $300-800
Dent removal $200-500
Windshield replacement $500-1,000
Excessive tire wear $150-200 per tire
Interior stains $100-300

Dealers typically cover normal wear and tear charges up to $500. Any amount beyond that becomes your responsibility. Professional repair costs exceed $1,000 in most cases, particularly with paint damage or major interior problems.

Stress of keeping your car pristine

A leased vehicle needs detailed service records and repair documentation throughout the term. Your maintenance responsibilities become crucial when you lease a car:

The need to keep your car looking perfect can really change how you drive it. A simple shopping cart in a parking lot becomes your wallet's enemy. You might catch yourself parking far away from other cars or skipping certain routes to avoid stone chips.

You should get your car checked about three months before your lease ends. This gives you enough time to fix problems and save money by choosing your own repair shop instead of paying the dealer's high rates.

Early Termination Penalties

Early termination of a car lease brings potential risks that most people fail to see. A careful review of your lease agreement's penalty clauses can help you avoid thousands in surprise charges down the road.

Contract breaches can get pricey

Breaking your lease early leads to hefty penalties. These costs might hit your wallet:

Termination Type Typical Costs
Early Exit Fee $300-500
Remaining Payments Full amount due
Processing Charges $200-400
Vehicle Transport $150-300

The leasing company will demand all remaining lease payments plus an early termination fee. A lease with 24 months remaining at $400 monthly means you could owe $9,600 plus additional penalties.

Lack of flexibility

A lease agreement can trap you with limited choices. The standard contracts leave you with little room to adapt when:

Financial risks

Breaking your lease early will affect your financial health in several ways:

Your credit score might drop by 50-100 points if you don't handle the termination the right way. This hit to your credit score could stay on your report for up to seven years.

Early termination costs are a big deal as it means that $10,000 or more, based on your remaining lease term. You'll likely need another vehicle too, which doubles your transportation expenses.

Lease transfers or buyouts offer some options, but they come with their own price tags. A lease transfer sets you back $300-500 in fees. Buyouts need you to pay both the remaining lease balance and the vehicle's residual value.

Take time to review your long-term transportation needs before signing on the dotted line. The money you save from lower monthly payments might not be worth it if you need flexibility later, since breaking a lease costs much more.

Limited Customization Options

Knowing how to personalize and modify a leased vehicle comes with major restrictions that limit your driving experience. You should review these limitations before signing a lease agreement to avoid pricey mistakes and disappointment.

Restrictions on modifications

Your lease agreement limits vehicle modifications unless you get permission from your lessor. Let's look at what you can and cannot modify:

Modification Type Typically Allowed? Requirements
Window Tinting Sometimes Dealer installation only
Wheel/Tire Changes Yes Must restore originals
Audio System Limited No permanent changes
Paint/Wraps Rarely Written approval needed
Performance Parts No Voids warranty

Customizing Your Leased Vehicle

A leased vehicle allows some temporary modifications, but you must follow these rules:

These strict rules create a practical challenge. You need to keep both the original parts and your custom modifications. This approach doubles your costs and prevents you from adding lasting value to the vehicle.

Resale value considerations

Modifications can substantially affect your lease-end obligations:

The total expense of installing and later removing modifications ranges from $500 to several thousand, based on the changes made. These costs add to your regular lease payments and provide no long-term value.

Your lease agreement determines whether dealer-approved modifications need removal before returning the vehicle. The safest approach treats your leased vehicle as a temporary possession, so save major modifications for a car you own.

Dependency on Good Credit

Car lease approvals need strong credit scores. This makes lease financing nowhere near as available as most people think. Your credit history affects your approval chances and lease terms by a lot.

Credit score requirements

Car lease approval demands a surprisingly high credit score. The average credit score needed for approval is 737, which exceeds the national average of 715. Your lease prospects depend on your credit tier:

Credit Score Range Approval Likelihood Interest Rate Impact
750+ Excellent Lowest rates available
700-749 Good Slightly higher rates
650-699 Fair Substantially higher rates
Below 650 Poor Limited options, very high rates

Effect on approval and rates

Your credit score directly determines your monthly payments through the money factor (lease equivalent of interest rate). Someone with a score below 700 could pay $50-150 more per month for the same vehicle than a person with excellent credit.

A poor credit score results in:

Alternatives for lower credit scores

Your lease approval chances can improve with several options when your credit score isn't ideal:

Alternative What It All Means
Larger down payment 10-20% of vehicle value
Security deposit 1-2 times monthly payment
Co-signer addition No direct cost
Lease transfer $300-500 transfer fee

Credit requirements differ among dealers, so it helps to shop around. Dealerships that work with lower credit scores exist, but they usually charge more. Better terms become available with a good-credit co-signer, though they share equal responsibility for payments.

Your application needs extra documentation to succeed. Bank statements covering the last 3-6 months and recent pay stubs make your case stronger. You'll also need proof of income, residence history, and detailed employment records.

Each lease application creates a hard credit inquiry that temporarily affects your credit score. The smart approach is to submit all applications within a 14-day window. Credit bureaus count multiple inquiries during this period as one single check.

Complex Agreements

Lease agreements often read like a foreign language. The contract has many complex terms and conditions that could substantially affect your financial obligations.

Confusing terms and conditions

Your lease agreement's money factor operates differently than standard interest rates. The equivalent APR calculation requires multiplying the money factor by 2,400. Here are some examples:

The lease agreement has several fees that impact your total cost:

Fee Type Typical Range When Charged
Acquisition Fee $395-895 Lease start
Assignment Fee $400-600 Processing
Security Deposit One month's payment Lease start
Disposition Fee $300-400 Lease end

Hidden clauses

Your lease agreement has several subtle requirements that might lead to extra charges:

Getting the Full Picture Before Signing

These steps are crucial before you sign your lease agreement:

  1. Calculate the total cost including all fees and charges
  2. Verify the agreed-upon vehicle price (capitalized cost)
  3. Understand the residual value calculation
  4. Review mileage allowances and overage charges
  5. Check wear-and-tear definitions

The lease agreement comes with strict insurance coverage requirements. You'll need full coverage with specific minimum limits that are usually higher than what you might choose for a purchased vehicle.

The residual value affects your monthly payments by a lot. This value shows how much the car should be worth when the lease ends and is usually shown as a percentage of MSRP. Lower monthly payments usually come with a higher residual value, but buying the vehicle at lease end could cost more.

Early termination rules in lease contracts can be complex. You might owe thousands more than expected if you end the lease early. Reading and understanding these terms before signing protects you from unexpected costs later.

No Investment Potential

Traditional investments grow your money over time, but a vehicle lease drains your wallet without giving anything back. The monthly payments disappear completely and you end up with nothing to show for your money.

Lack of resale value benefit

Leasing a car means you give up any potential resale value. To cite an instance, see this financial comparison over a 6-year period:

Financial Aspect Leasing (2 leases) Buying
Monthly Payments $500 x 72 $550 x 72
Total Paid $36,000 $39,600
Asset Value $0 $15,000
Net Financial Position -$36,000 -$24,600

Missed chance for asset appreciation

Most cars lose value over time, but some models can keep their most important value. You miss these potential benefits:

Comparison with owning

Your finances look completely different when you own a car instead of leasing it. A 36-month lease will cost you about $18,000 with nothing to show for it afterward. But if you buy the same car, you'll have an asset worth about $19,500 after the same time period, even after it loses value.

Owning a car becomes an even better deal as time passes. After you pay off your car loan, you can:

Here's something to think about: A $36,000 car typically drops in value to $19,500 after three years. As the owner, you get to decide what to do with that remaining value. You could keep driving the car without payments for several more years, while someone leasing would need to start making new payments on another lease.

The money-making potential gets even better with certain types of cars. Some models, especially limited editions or popular brands, hold onto 40% more value than regular cars. Leasing means you'll miss out on these chances to make money.

Monthly lease payments cover the time when the car loses value fastest, and you don't build any ownership. You pay for the most expensive part of the car's life while someone else owns it. This means your money goes toward something that won't give you anything back.

The financial picture gets worse when you add up missed opportunities. Money spent on lease payments could help you own your car instead. This ownership becomes a valuable asset you can use for future purchases or emergencies.

Market conditions can change car values quickly. Recent supply chain problems caused used car prices to jump. Car owners could take advantage of these higher prices, but people leasing stayed stuck in their contracts without any way to benefit from these changes.

Lack of Long-Term Stability

Car leasing creates an endless cycle of payments. You'll face constant vehicle changes and these decisions will affect your long-term financial health. Smart transportation choices depend on your clear understanding of these ongoing financial commitments.

Frequent vehicle changes

Lease agreements typically require you to switch vehicles every 24-36 months. This creates an ongoing cycle of transitions that affects your finances:

Lease Cycle Total Payments Over 10 Years
2-year leases 5 vehicles, $60,000
3-year leases 3-4 vehicles, $54,000
4-year leases 2-3 vehicles, $48,000

New transitions mean more paperwork, possible credit checks, and additional down payments. The inception fees cost $1,000-3,000 each time you begin a new lease. These changeover expenses can accumulate to $15,000 or more across a decade.

Ongoing monthly payments

A never-ending stream of payments creates a financial trap that's tough to break free from. Car buyers eventually finish their payments, but lease customers face continuous expenses that include:

This payment cycle continues because you lease vehicles when they lose value fastest. A standard 36-month lease demands $400-500 each month, and future leases will cost more as vehicle prices climb.

Impact on financial planning

Continuous lease cycles can wreck your long-term financial stability. The effects touch every part of your money situation.

Your financial planning gets tough because you must:

Each new lease application puts your credit score under the microscope. Your chances to get other loans or credit cards might suffer from multiple credit checks. You'll also need top-notch credit to get good lease terms, since most lessors want scores above 700.

Monthly budgets become shaky because lease payments go up with each new contract. A car that costs $400 monthly now could jump to $450-500 monthly for its newer model in three years. These rising costs make it hard to save for a house or retirement.

Life changes become harder to handle. Moving for work, having kids, or money emergencies get complicated with lease agreements hanging over your head. Breaking a lease early hits you with thousands in penalties, and buying it out means coming up with big money fast.

Money problems stack up as time goes by. A $450 monthly lease for ten years adds up to $54,000 just in payments. This doesn't count down payments, fees, or insurance costs. That money could grow to over $72,000 with a modest 6% yearly return - showing how much money leasing costs you in the long run.

Car expenses stay fixed in your budget forever. Unlike owning a car that's paid off, which you can keep driving when money gets tight, lease payments keep coming whatever your financial situation. This lack of flexibility can hurt during tough economic times or unexpected events.

Conclusion

Car leasing traps you in endless payments and puts strict limits on how you use the vehicle. The monthly payments look attractive at first but hide the most important expenses through mileage caps, wear-and-tear fees, and early exit penalties. Lease contracts just need excellent credit scores and you must watch the vehicle's condition carefully throughout the term. These agreements also restrict your customization choices.

Purchasing a vehicle gives you clear financial benefits over leasing through equity building and keeps its value longer. Your bought vehicle becomes an asset you own, removes mileage restrictions, and lets you customize it however you want. Smart buyers can drive without payments after paying off their loan and keep full control of their transportation needs without getting stuck in the never-ending payment cycle that comes with leasing.

FAQs

What are the financial disadvantages of leasing a car?

Leasing a car often results in higher overall costs compared to purchasing a vehicle outright. When you lease, you make regular payments but do not own the car at the end of the lease term, which means you have nothing to trade in or sell. This can result in paying more over time, especially for those who lease vehicles repeatedly.

What are the primary reasons to avoid leasing a vehicle?

One of the main reasons to avoid leasing is that you do not gain ownership of the vehicle despite making significant payments. Additionally, leases often come with various restrictions and additional costs that can make them less appealing than buying a car.

Does financial expert Dave Ramsey recommend leasing vehicles?

Dave Ramsey strongly advises against leasing vehicles. He argues that leasing is financially imprudent and refers to car leases as "fleeces," highlighting that they are generally unfavorable financial decisions.

What is considered the biggest drawback of leasing a vehicle?

The most significant drawback of leasing a vehicle is the set of limitations it imposes, such as mileage caps, which typically range from 10,000 to 15,000 miles per year. Other notable disadvantages include additional costs, difficulty in terminating the lease early, and the fact that you do not own the vehicle at the end of the lease.

Is it financially sensible to lease a car if I can afford to buy one outright?

While leasing might seem like a good option if you prefer not to spend a large amount upfront, it generally results in higher total expenditure over time. For example, leasing a high-value car like a 2023 Acura Integra ASPEC Tech or a 2023 MB CLA250 can cost significantly over a three-year period, often amounting to about half the car's total value, without the benefit of ownership at the end of the lease.

July 22, 2021 — 18 min read

11 bold ways to boost your financial health

Josh Pigford

Josh Pigford
June 5, 2024 — 10 min read

How the Market Works: Demystifying Stock Market Operations

Josh Pigford

Josh Pigford
June 21, 2022 — 11 min read

Investing during recessions and bear markets

Josh Pigford

Josh Pigford

Join the Maybe Maybe Logo waitlist

Join the waitlist to get notified when a hosted version of the app is available.

Don't want to wait? Self-host an early version of Maybe.

Maybe Screenshot